Reply to newsletter emails via email
Open, LowPublic



Allow readers who subscribe to a blog via email to reply directly to an email they receive.


A minimally-viable commenting system.


Requirement: this is an opt-in feature to enable replies via email.

Goal: ideally, we'd provide a proxy / relay email address (e.g. or that would keep the author's true email address private.

We then have two options, depending on how much privacy correspondents need / abuse we anticipate:

High privacy:

The author could then reply to a proxy / relay address (e.g., which would forward to the original commenter's true email address. Both parties would have their real email address hidden.

Lower privacy:

The author can reply directly to the commenter. (Note: This probably makes the most sense. We mostly want to protect the author from unwanted abuse; but if they reply, they're choosing to engage, and we can assume all is good.)


  • Add a new option when enabling email subscribers: Enable replies via email
    • Include help documentation / tutorials on this
  • When enabled, include a Reply-To header, pointing to a special email address that is connected to the individual subscriber
    • This enables potentially invalidating the email address via platform for abusive subscribers (in the future)
  • The special email address should:
    • Receive replies
    • Validate the address, check against anti-abuse lists (future)
    • Send the message to the email address on the post author's account, with Reply-To set to the commenter's actual email address

Related Objects


Event Timeline

matt triaged this task as Low priority.Sep 28 2020, 1:24 PM
matt created this task.
matt moved this task from Far Future to Soon on the board.
matt moved this task from Future to Q1 2021 - Jan-Mar on the Roadmap board.